Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
as published in the American Journal of Surgery (February 2010, Volume 199, Number 2)
Jennifer L. Walden, MD, FACSAssociate Attending
Program Director, Aesthetic Surgery Fellowship
Manhattan Eye, Ear, and Throat Hospital
50 East 71st Street
New York, New York 10021
www.drjenniferwalden.com
212-288-9009
Linda G. Phillips, MD, FACS
Truman G. Blocker Distinguished Professor and Chief
Division of Plastic Surgery
Senior Associate Dean for Faculty Affairs, School of Medicine
University of Texas Medical Branch
Division of Plastic Surgery 301 University Blvd., 0724
Galveston TX 77555 - 0724
Phone: 409-772-1257
Fax: 409-772-1872
Chair, American Board of Plastic Surgery
University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, TX
Abstract: The American Board of Plastic Surgery, Inc. was
organized in June 1937 by representatives of various groups
interested in this type of surgery, and received recognition as a
subsidiary of the American Board of Surgery in May 1938. The American
Board of Plastic Surgery, Inc. was given the status of a major
specialty board in May 1941 by action of the Advisory Board for
Medical Specialties as approved by the Council on Medical Education
of the American Medical Association. Plastic surgery is a broad-based
discipline with emphasis on areas such as breast,
cranio-maxillofacial, burn, aesthetic, and hand surgery as well as
complex wounds and wound healing. Areas of technological research in
the field include fetal wound healing, stem cell and tissue
regeneration. Plastic surgery as a specialty captures a great deal of
media attention over many other fields of medicine, so education,
training, and credentialing have become an area of national interest.
The purpose of this article is to provide information on the
organization, basic requirements for training, fellowship, and
volunteer opportunities within the specialty.
Keywords: Plastic and reconstructive surgery, plastic surgery,
plastic surgery training, plastic surgery residency, cosmetic
surgery, cosmetic surgery training, aesthetic surgery, aesthetic
surgery training, plastic surgery fellowship, board-certified plastic
surgeon, American Board of Plastic Surgery.
Residency Requirements
There are two major pathways toward obtaining acceptable graduate level training in plastic surgery including the Independent Model and the Integrated Model.
Independent model - In an independent model, the resident
must complete both full pre-requisite general surgery training and
requisite training in plastic surgery. A minimum prerequisite of
three years of clinical training in general surgery in the same
program used to be required. Now, the independent program requires
full pre-requisite training, so the three years of general surgery is
not accepted. The independent program in plastic surgery is now three
years long, and the integrated is six. Broad surgical training
experience is required. Prospective candidates may have also
completed an accredited residency training program in neurosurgery,
orthopaedic surgery, otolaryngology, or urology. Satisfactory
completion of a residency program in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
approved by the American Dental Association is an alternate pathway
for prerequisite training prior to plastic surgery residency.
Information concerning accredited training programs for both the
Independent and Integrated Models may be found in the Directory of
Graduate Medical Education ("the green book") published by the
American Medical Association (AMA). Copies of the directory are
available at most medical school libraries, and the information is
also available online at AMA’s Fellowship and Residency Electronic
Interactive Database (FREIDA) at
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/2997.html.
The Residency Review Committee (RRC) for Plastic Surgery inspects and
makes recommendations for or against approval of a residency training
program in plastic surgery only after the director of the residency
has filed an application for approval by the RRC.
Integrated Model - Residents must have a medical or osteopathic degree granted in the US or Canada by an institution accredited by the Liaison Committee for medical education (LCME) or American Osteopathic Association (AOA). Training of six years of clinical residency under the authority and direction of the plastic surgery program director is required. No less than two years of this program must be concentrated plastic surgery training and the final twelve months must entail senior clinical responsibility. Although there are certainly both independent and integrated models of training available, there is a growing trend towards matching competitive candidates out of medical school into integrated programs.
Residency - Requisite Training: Graduate Education in Plastic Surgery
Three years of
plastic surgery training is required, and the final year must be at
the senior level. Residents entering a plastic surgery residency
accredited for three years of training must complete the entire three
years, including one year of senior responsibility. Training in
plastic surgery must be obtained in either the US or Canada. Training
in plastic surgery must cover the entire spectrum of plastic surgery
and include experience in both the functional and aesthetic
management of congenital and acquired defects of the head, neck,
breast, trunk, and extremities.
This period of specialized training should emphasize the relationship
of basic science -- anatomy, pathology, biochemistry, and
microbiology -- to surgical principles fundamental to all branches of
surgery and especially plastic surgery. In addition, the training
program must provide in-depth exposure to the following subjects:
emergency care, shock, wound healing, blood replacement, fluid and
electrolyte balance, pharmacology, and anesthetics. Programs that
offer graduated, hands-on operative experience and responsibility for
trainees are important in the training of a competent, independent
plastic surgeon.
Board Certification
The board conducts two types of examinations including the Written
and Oral examinations.
The Written examination is given in the fall each year and consists
of multiple clinically oriented case-based questions. The exam is
administered via computer at approved testing facilities in the US.
The Oral examination is conducted in the fall each year as well, and
candidates will be deemed admissible to this exam only if they have
done the following:
- passed the written exam
- fulfilled sixteen months independent practice of plastic surgery as it applies to them
- submitted a seven month case list compilation acceptable to the Board
- are actively engaged primarily in the practice of plastic surgery and hold active operating privileges in a hospital.
The Board will select five cases from the candidate's compiled
seven month case list and request each candidate prepare case
reports. The Oral examination is given over two days. Effective 1995,
certificates issued by the Board are dated and will be valid for ten
years and revalidation will be accomplished by the Board's
Maintenance of Certification process. For more detailed information
on the specific training models in plastic surgery residency and
board certification process, visit the Website of the American Board
of Plastic Surgery at
www.abplsurg.org. The senior author
of this paper serves as the Chair of the American Board of Plastic
Surgery.
The Plastic Surgery Educational Foundation administers the PSEF Oral
and Written Board Preparation Course, which is held annually. It is
designed to concisely and interactively review the plastic surgery
principles and management problems presented on the test as well as
expose the test-taker to the oral board format.
Residency, Research and Subspecialty Fellowships
Medical Students
If a student is interested in plastic surgery, she or he should try and identify a mentor early. Doing a surgical clerkship in the junior and/or senior year is strongly encouraged in order to gain appreciation for the discipline and to become acquainted with a specific program and its members. Motivated students also tend to do "acting internships" and take call with the residents to increase their visibility within the program. High USMLE scores, high grades in medical school (including membership in Alpha Omega Alpha), strong letters of recommendation from other plastic surgeons, and research activity are generally helpful. Away rotations at specific programs are helpful for candidates who are interested in going to the program and feel that they need the additional exposure provided by a month at the outside institution. Given its increasingly competitive nature, only very rarely do spots go unmatched in the National Residency Matching Program (NRMP) plastic surgery integrated model programs.
Residents/Faculty
There are several
opportunities for research fellowships. The Plastic Surgery
Educational Foundation (PSEF) sponsors the Smile Train, Inc. and the
PSEF Cleft Lip and Palate Research Initiative Grant. This program
provides funds for healthcare professionals to perform meritorious
research projects in the areas of etiology, treatment, and care of
people with cleft lip and palate. The National Endowment for Plastic
Surgery through the PSEF also funds meritorious projects in the field
of plastic surgery.
Numerous philanthropic traveling fellowships exist including the
African Medical and Research Foundation (AMREF), Operation Smile,
Interplast, and Austin Smiles. More information regarding research
and giving back opportunities may be found at the American Society of
Plastic Surgeons Website at
www.plasticsurgery.org.
Postgraduate Fellowships
There are numerous 6 or 12-month dedicated subspecialty fellowships
to follow formal plastic surgery residency training if a surgeon
desires to obtain further exposure and experience in a certain area.
These include fellowships in aesthetic surgery, breast
reconstruction, microvascular surgery, hand surgery, burns, and more
recently post-bariatric surgical reconstruction after massive weight
loss.
Society Involvement and Membership
ASPS Residents and Fellows Forum
The American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) has established a Residents and Fellows Forum. Residents who join this group receive:
- Subscription to Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery(R) Scientific Journal (free courtesy of a grant from KCI)
- Subscription to Plastic Surgery News(R) (free courtesy of a grant from KCI)
- Free ASPS Annual Scientific Meeting registration and one free instructional course
- Discounts on select ASPS/PSEF programs, products and services
- Residents list serve
Joining the forum does not confer membership in the Society.
Rather, it serves as a way residents can become familiar with the
benefits of Society membership and to maintain communication with the
Society.
Those plastic surgeons who have become Candidates for Active
Membership are eligible to become active members in the ASPS after
they have completed a formal application process which may be
reviewed on the ASPS Website.
The ASPS Young Plastic Surgeons Committee identifies problems or
concerns of the young plastic surgeon. The term young is used to
connote physicians in training or those newly established in the
practice. The committee participates in the annual Senior Residents
Conference promoting membership and participation in the ASPS and by
offering assistance to residents in career planning. As well, the YPS
recommends final candidates to the AMA Plastic Surgery Caucus and
nominates candidates for delegate positions to the AMA Young
Physicians Section.
ASAPS Candidate Program
The American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ASAPS) has
implemented a Candidate Program to assist qualified plastic surgeons
with their aesthetic surgery education while introducing them to the
Society and its programs. As the plastic surgery organization
exclusively concerned with the education of aesthetic plastic
surgeons, ASAPS offers many programs and services and recognizes its
obligation to make its expanding educational and support services
available to the broader community of plastic surgeons.
The Candidate Program provides nonmember plastic surgeons the
opportunity for substantial economic savings on ASAPS-sponsored
continuing education meetings and other services to benefit one’s
practice. The first author of this paper serves as the Vice-Chair of
the Candidate Liaison Committee of ASAPS. The functions of the
Committee are to coordinate candidate program activities and to
promote membership in the Society.
Other key societies within the field of plastic surgery include but
are not limited to the following: American Association of Plastic
Surgeons, International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery,
American Association for Hand Surgery, American Burn Association,
American Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Association, American College of
Surgeons, American Society of Maxillofacial Surgeons, Plastic Surgery
Research Council, and American Society for Reconstructive
Microsurgery.
Each society has specific criteria for membership with varying levels
of training, sponsorship, and benefits. As well, each society tends
to have its own annual scientific meeting for its members, residents,
and candidates for membership. Research opportunities are available
by submitting material for paper or poster presentation at these
meetings. Society journals also accept original work for publication
for those interested in this aspect of plastic surgery. For a
detailed list of societies and annual meetings visit the
ASPS
Website.
Journals
A number of journals deal entirely
with plastic surgery topics, and some of them offer discounts to
residents. The following is a partial list of some key journals, but
a complete list is available with subscription information on the
ASPS
Website.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery - Journal of the American
Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons, Inc. ("the white
journal")
Aesthetic Surgery Journal - Official publication of the
American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery
Aesthetic Plastic Surgery - Official publication of the
International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery
Journal of Hand Surgery
Annals of Plastic Surgery
Clinics in Plastic Surgery
British Journal of Plastic Surgery
Journal of Reconstructive Microsurgery
The Plastic Surgery Educational Foundation offers a guide for
students interested in pursuing their education in plastic surgery
called “Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Essentials for Students.”
It is available free of charge and entirely downloadable on the ASPS
Website at the following link:
http://www.plasticsurgery.org/medical_professionals/publications/Essentials-for-Students.cfm
Although a career in plastic surgery is a marathon and not a race,
the authors have both found it to be a very rewarding endeavor.
Continued education, fine technical skill, and endurance are
certainly prerequisites, but we wish anyone who considers it the
best of luck in their future.
References
The American Board of Plastic Surgery, Inc.
Primary Booklet of Information, 21-46, 2000. Seven Penn Center,
Suite 400, 1635 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103-2204;
www.abplsurg.org (accessed February
17, 2008).
The American Society of Plastic Surgeons Website:
www.plasticsurgery.org (accessed
2001, and February 2008).
The American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery Website:
www.surgery.org (accessed February
2008).
Chang, P., Korman, JM, Rockwell, WB, and Wong, GB. Resource Book for
Plastic Surgery Residents, In ASPS Website,
www.plasticsurgery.org (accessed
2001).
Further inquiries may be directed to:
Jennifer L. Walden, MD, FACS
50 East 71st Street
New York, New York 10021
www.drjenniferwalden.com










