Martha K. Terris, MD
Professor of Surgery, Urology
Medical College of Georgia
Augusta, GA
Although classified as a surgical subspecialty, urology focuses on
both the surgical and medical management of diseases of the male and
female urinary tract as well as the male reproductive organs. As a
result, urology presents a wide spectrum of practice opportunities,
ranging from office practice to minimally invasive endoscopies to
major open surgical procedures. This variety is a particularly
attractive feature of urology.
Urinary stone
disease has been the mainstay of urologic practice since ancient
times. The highly morbid surgical procedures of early urologists were
primarily designed remove bladder stones, usually via a perineal
approach. Positioning patients for such procedures resulted in the
term "lithotomy position" which is still commonly used today for both
urological and non-urological procedures. Rigid and flexible
ureteroscopy, percutaneous endoscopic methods of renal stone
fragmentation/ removal, and extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy have
largely rendered open surgical procedures for urinary stone disease
obsolete. In addition, advances in the understanding and diagnostic
techniques for metabolic disorders that cause stone disease has
resulted in improvements in the medical management of
nephrolithiasis, reducing the risk of recurrent stone formation.
Another disorder
which has historically distinguished urology from other surgical
fields is obstructive uropathy. Removing obstruction in the urinary
collecting system in order to preserve and improve renal function
and/or relieve discomfort is typically perceived to involve the
reduction of bladder outlet obstruction caused by benign prostatic
hyperplasia in older men. However, the treatment of obstructive
uropathy encompasses a wide range of disease processes and patient
populations, including the correction of congenital posterior
urethral valves or ureteropelvic junction obstruction in children. In
fact, the urinary tract is affected by congenital anomalies more than
any other organ system. These congenital abnormalities run the gamut
from the relatively common problem of the undescended testis to the
complex area of ambiguous genitalia. Most urologists routinely repair
the typical congenital urologic anomalies in children, but the more
complex problems are often referred to urologists with specialized
training in pediatric urology.
The detection and
treatment of urologic cancers is a large portion of most urologic
practices. The largest proportion of urologic oncology practice is
usually spent in the diagnosis and treatment of prostate cancer. In
addition, urologists commonly perform open surgical procedures for
renal, bladder, and prostatic malignancies. The same endoscopic
skills utilized by urologists to treat urinary stone disease are
frequently employed for diagnosis and management of most cases of
transitional cell carcinoma. These endoscopic approaches have
expanded to include laparoscopy for the performance of nephrectomy
for appropriate renal cell carcinomas. Laparoscopic performance of
other urologic cancer surgery is performed in referral centers. For
advanced tumors, the development of multimodal therapy, in which
chemotherapy, radiation therapy, and surgical treatment are used in
conjunction, have yielded dramatic successes in the treatment of
testis tumors and Wilms' tumor. Similar multimodal regimens are being
developed for other advanced genitourinary malignancies.
Male sexual
dysfunction and infertility are commonly treated by urologists;
however, the introduction of oral medications for impotence has
opened this field to internists and general practitioners. Other
non-surgical therapies are also available for erectile dysfunction.
For individuals failing less invasive management, urologists can
restore function by the placement of a prosthetic device. The area of
prosthetics in urology not only encompasses the various forms of
penile prostheses, but also artificial urinary sphincters. The
management of male infertility has generally focused on the surgical
ligation of varicoceles and relief of acquired and congenital
obstructions within the genital system. Advanced in vitro
fertilization techniques, particularly the ability to perform
intracytoplasmic injection of a single sperm into an ovum, has
stimulated the development of microscopic testicular dissection to
retrieve sperm and improve the chances of fathering a child for
significantly subfertile men.
Few areas within
the scope of urology are shared with other surgical specialties.
Urologists may serve as primary or assistant surgeons for renal
transplantation procedures and may perform other areas types of
vascular surgery such as microvascular surgical procedures performed
for certain cases of impotence and renal artery reconstruction in
patients with renovascular hypertension. Urologists also often play a
substantial role in the evaluation and surgical treatment of adrenal
disorders. Trauma to the genitourinary system often involves the
urologist as one member of the trauma team during the initial
evaluation of the multiply-injured patient. Urinary tract infections
affect every age group in both sexes thus there is inevitably a large
cross-disciplinary approach to this problem with Urologists
interacting with internists, pediatricians, and gynecologists in the
management of patients with bacteriuria. In addition to stone
disease, congenital malformations, and malignancies, which occur in
both genders, there are urologic problems seen almost entirely in
women such as stress urinary incontinence and interstitial cystitis.
In addition to urologists, these female urologic disorders, may be
treated by some gynecologists. Many fellowship training programs in
urogynecology accept both urologists and gynecologists.
Residency
Requirements
The field of
urology has long been a desirable specialty, attracting some of the
most competitive medical students. The urology match typically takes
place in January, in contrast to the National Residency Matching
Program (NRMP) match, which usually occurs in March. Due to this
timing, the urology match is commonly referred to as an "early"
match. The early match allows students who do not match with a
urology training program to enter the NRMP match for alternatives
without having to wait a full year until the next match takes place.
Applicant interviews with urology training programs typically occur
October through December. In 2000, there were 113 civilian urology
residency programs accepting a total of 230 first year
residents. Individuals participating in the urology match are
encouraged to rank several programs to increase their chances of
obtaining a training position. For more about the urology matching
program, contact the
American Urological Association Office of
Education, 2425 West Loop South, Suite 333, Houston, TX
77027-4207. In 2003 urology residency programs began participating in
the matching program administered through the American Association of
Medical College's centralized Electronic Residency Application
Service (ERAS) matching system. Previously, resident applicants were
required to submit separate applications to each prospective program
in formats that varied from institution to institution. Access to the
ERAS system is available
here. For individuals who have
already completed a portion of residency training in urology or other
fields and are seeking vacancies in urology residency programs, see a
current list
here.
First and second
year medical students considering urology as a specialty should
identify members of the urology faculty at their medical school who
are willing to review their curriculum vitae and offer specific
advise regarding enhancing their application. Generally, if the
student's schedule allows, participation in a research project will
improve the chances of matching with a program high on their list.
The more in-depth the research, the more the application is enhanced.
Research does not necessarily have to be in the field of urology to
boost one's application. If the student is unsure of having adequate
time to complete a project, however, she should not obligate herself.
Failing to follow-through on the research commitment will reflect
more poorly on the applicant than the lack of any research
experience.
Classroom
performance is important as many top programs use class rank or other
honors as criteria for an invitation for an interview. Similarly, a
student's performance on Parts 1 and 2 of the National Board of
Medical Examiners licensing examination is also considered during the
review of applications by urology residency programs.
Medical students
interested in urology should participate in a urology rotation at
their home institution late in their junior year or early in their
senior year. Students should strive to perform their best during this
rotation. Once becoming familiar with the faculty, prospective
urology residents should solicit letters of recommendation from the
urology leadership at their medical school. Participating in a
urology rotation at an institution other than the student's home
institution may be beneficial if it is a program at which the student
is particularly interested completing residency training. A visiting
student rotation can also give students the chance to impress the
urology faculty at another institution if their clinical skills
outweigh their academic record or who attend a medical school of
lesser reputation.
Other elective
clinical rotations to consider during medical school include general
surgery, renal transplantation, pediatric surgery, nephrology,
neurology, gynecology, radiology, pathology, and anesthesia.
Residency
Urologic residency
training consists of a minimum of 5 years of clinical postgraduate
education of which 12 months must be spent in general surgery and 36
months must be spent in clinical urology. The remaining 12 months
must be spent in general surgery, urology, or other clinical
disciplines relevant to urology. The final 12 months must be spent as
a chief resident in urology with appropriate clinical responsibility.
The Society of
Women in Urology (SWIU) has published a handbook for female urology
residents with tips on surviving, and excelling, during residency.
This handbook is provided at no cost to female urology residents
(usually sent automatically if residents have matched in their
residency position through the AUA matching service) or can be
purchased for approximately $10 through the
SWIU website.
Board Certification
Board
certification in urology is a multiple step procedure. The American
Board of Urology (ABU) arranges and conducts this process. Initially
the written, or "qualifying," examination is taken; this test is
given in June of each year. The two-day qualifying exam consists of
standard multiple-choice format of questions about anatomy,
pathophysiology, and therapy of urologic diseases as well as
interpretation of pathological and radiological images. It is usually
taken during the final, chief resident, year of residency training,
and must be taken (or re-taken if failed initially) within five years
after completing an approved urology residency. After successful
passage of the qualifying examination and completion of 18-months of
post-residency urologic practice, the oral, or "certifying,"
examination is taken. A log of cases performed, any complications,
and letters of recommendation from peers during the 18-months of
post-residency practice must be submitted and approved by the ABU
prior to taking the oral examination. This exam is given in February
of each year and must be taken within five years of successful
completion of the written examination. Over the past decade,
approximately 80% of the candidates taking the written qualifying
examination have passed, with the highest passing rate being among
United States Medical School graduates. The certifying examination
also has a failure rate of about 20%. Certification is for a 10-year
period with recertification required after that time. For more
information, see the
ABU website.
Fellowship Training
Most urologists in
private practice are generalists and see a gamut of diseases ranging
from benign prostatic enlargement (BPH), stones, incontinence, and
cancer. There are recognized areas of subspecialization within
urology, which are common among urologists at academic centers and in
large group practices. Individuals interested in subspecialization
usually acquire additional fellowship training after residency. There
are multiple research fellowships available, most of which are
sponsored through the
American Foundation for Urological Disease.
Other fellowships, ranging from 1 to 3 years in length, combine
research and clinical training in subspecialty areas such as
Pediatric Urology, Male Infertility/Andrology, Female/Reconstructive
Urology, Urologic Oncology, and EndoUrology. Many fellowship
positions can be found on the
CareerMD website,
while other positions are listed only by individual institutions or
specialty societies.
Pediatric
urologists specialize in the treatment of genitourinary disorders in
infants, children, adolescents, and young adults. Most of the
diseases seen by this subspecialty are congenital but urinary tract
infections, pediatric renal and testicular malignancies, and
dysfunctional voiding also contribute to the patient population. The
specialty of pediatric urology is closely aligned with the American
Academy of Pediatrics and most fellowship-trained pediatric
urologists become fellows of this organization. Most fellowships are
1 year in duration. A list of Pediatric Urology fellowship programs
can be found through the
Society of Pediatric Urology website,
which is administered at the University of Alabama Birmingham.
There are 1-2 year
fellowship positions in Male infertility which focus on the
microsurgical techniques of relieving obstructions in the male
reproductive tract as well as sperm retrieval and manipulation of the
male hormonal status to improve sperm quality. Some fellowships,
often referred to as Andrology fellowships, teach trainees about a
broader range of male reproductive difficulties and include training
in the evaluation and treatment of male erectile dysfunction in
addition to infertility management. Information on some of the
available Infertility/Andrology fellowships can be found at http://www.maleinfertility.org/training.html,
http://www.urol.bcm.tmc.edu/fellowships.html,
http://www.clevelandclinic.org/reproductiveresearchcenter/training.html,
and
http://urology.northwestern.edu/education/fellowship.html.
Female/Pelvic
Reconstructive Surgery or Urogynecology Fellowships are available as
purely urology subspecialty training, or as training for both
urologists and gynecologists. The fellowships accepting both
specialties require 3 years of training for gynecologists and 2 years
for urologists. Despite the longer time commitment, gynecologists
predominantly choose these fellowships and most are accredited by The
American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology. Most of these
multidisciplinary fellowships participate in the NRMP match; a list
of these fellowships can be found on the
American Urogynecology Society website. Urology residents
frequently apply to female urology fellowship programs that are not
conducted in conjunction with a gynecology service. In addition to
the surgical treatment of pelvic prolapse, the training provided in
these 1- to 2-year programs also encompasses diagnosis and treatment
of neurogenic bladder dysfunction, interstitial cystitis, and other
diseases affecting bladder emptying.
Urologic Oncology
fellowships train individuals on the care of patients with urologic
malignancies. These 2-year training programs involve learning the
techniques necessary to perform some of the most complex open
surgical cases in the field as well as supportive medical care for at
least one year. At least one year of research is generally required
during urologic oncology fellowships. More information about urologic
oncology fellowships can be found on the
Society of Urologic Oncology website.
EndoUrology has
historically been a specialty focusing on procedures performed during
cystoscopy, ureteroscopy, and percutaneous nephroscopy. In recent
years, the focus of this specialty has switched to laparoscopic
procedures resulting in a surge of interest in this type of training.
Some programs offer 3- to 6-month mini-fellowships that are designed
primarily to update the skills of practicing urologists rather than
focused post-residency subspecialization, which requires 1 year of
training. A list of the 1-year fellowship programs in Endourology can
be found
here. A matching program, similar to
residency match, debuted in 2002 for positions available in the
2003-2004 academic year. The deadline for applications is in April of
the chief resident year.
Funding Opportunities
The major funding
sources for urological research are
American Foundation for Urological Disease and two
branches of the NIH, the
National Institute of Diabetes & Digestive &
Kidney Diseases and the
National Cancer Institute.
Applications for research funds are also successful through the
Department of Defense and the
Veterans Administration.
Private
organizations accepting applications for research funding for the
study of urologic diseases include the
National Kidney Foundation, the
American Cancer Society, and
CAPCure.
Membership in
Societies
While some
urologists join subspecialty societies, such as those mentioned
above, most urologists become members of the American Urological
Association (AUA), the primary urological society in the United
States. The AUA publishes the Journal of Urology, as well as
educational programs, treatment guidelines, practice policies, and
other useful information. Many academic urologists belong to the
Society of University Urologists, which serves as the
Chairmen/Program Directors committee for the specialty and decides
policies on residency and fellowship issues.
There are just
over 200 board certified women in the field of urology as well as
approximately 100 female urology residents, fellows, post-residency,
and pre-board-certified women. These women comprise less than 2% of
the urologists in the United States. The Society of Women in Urology
allows the small number of women urologists to meet and discuss
issues and experiences and provide mentoring to those still in
training. The society also has representatives in key committees
within the American Urological Association. To find out more, log
onto the
SWIU website.
Conclusions
The field of
urology offers a broad range of patient care opportunities. This
diversity is what attracts many urologists to the specialty, but it
also allows the urologist to adapt her practice to her own talents
and circumstances. A practice can be designed to attract patients
needing major surgical procedures. Or, if performing outpatient
endoscopies and office practice are more appealing, such a practice
can be quite successful. For example, a young surgeon may initially
enjoy performing major oncologic, pediatric, or reconstructive
procedures but she may elect to perform minor surgical procedures
with a full- or part-time office practice when pregnant or when she
nears retirement age. With the aging population and the continued
rise in the number of patients with BPH, prostate cancer,
incontinence, impotence, and infertility, urologists expect to stay
quite busy in the coming years.
|